Build your own 12-pack

Build your own 12-pack

Giant, gourmet, hand-crafted cookies baked in small batches — made to share (or not). Each box weighs 3 pounds.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 rating on Google

Regular price $0.00
Unit price per
Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.

Customize your 6-pack or save with free shipping on a 12-pack

Intro offer: Use code COOKIE6 at checkout to get your first box for $35 (+shipping).
⭐ Real customer reactions

SHIPS EVERY TUESDAY. Baked fresh and shipped from Fort Wayne, Indiana. Order before Tuesday for delivery this week.

🚚 We bake and ship with care - fast ground shipping for $7 nationwide.

  • Free shipping over $50
  • Freeze and save for later
  • Share with friends

Important note (not visible on storefront)

This product has been automatically created by the Boxi app to bundle the purchased box products into a single bundle product in the cart and at the checkout.
  1. You can change the title or featured image to match your box design
  2. Always keep this product active and available on your webstore
  3. Do not delete this product, otherwise the bundling will stop working
  4. Do not make this product as draft, do not archive this product, do not remove from "Online Store" sales channel or markets, otherwise the bundling will stop working.
Cookie lineup
Shipping

Orders are baked fresh and shipped from Fort Wayne, Indiana. We bake once a week so your cookies are always peak fresh — never mass produced, never sitting on a shelf. Once shipped, orders will be delivered in 2 to 5 days depending on your location.

  • $7 flat-rate shipping to the United States (excluding Alaska and Hawaii)
  • Free shipping on orders over $50 (excluding Alaska and Hawaii)

Our cookies are individually wrapped to ensure they arrive fresh and delicious. For more details on delivery times and our policies, please visit our Shipping FAQ.

Note: WE SHIP ORDERS ON TUESDAY ONLY so we can bake fresh and ship quickly to your door. Order before Tuesday to ensure your cookies ship on Tuesday. If you order on Tuesday, your cookies will ship the following Tuesday.

Cookie care

Your cookies are made with the freshest ingredients and baked to order. To ensure they stay delicious, here are a few tips for proper care.

Freshness & Storing

For the best taste and texture, enjoy your cookies within 4-5 days of receiving them. To keep them fresh, store them in their sealed package or an airtight container at room temperature. Avoid placing them in an unsealed container or uncovered in the refrigerator, as this will cause them to dry out quickly.

Freezing & Thawing

If you want to save your cookies for later, they freeze beautifully! Simply place them in an airtight container and freeze for up to 3-4 months. When you're ready to enjoy them, thaw the cookies in the same airtight container at room temperature before serving.

Allergens

We make our cookies by hand using shared equipment. We are not an allergen-free bakery.

If needed, you can view our complete ingredients list.

Cookies in the box

This section doesn’t currently include any content. Add content to this section using the sidebar.

Our ingredients

King Arthur Flour

We start every batch with unbleached, unenriched King Arthur flour. There's no bleach, no bromate, and zero preservatives. We buy it 12 pounds at a time because we can't find it in bulk.

what our customers say

"Hands down the best cookies we've ever had!" - Keri D.

The cookie that started it all

The Dad Bod. Crispy edges and a gooey inside. Available in Chaos & Crumbs and Death by Chocolate. It's never left our menu.

from personal trainer to cookie dealer

I was a personal trainer and hobby cyclist. Then I was diagnosed with an autoimmune disorder.

I shifted gears and started experimenting with cookie recipes. Since then, they started selling out at the local farmers market. Now those same cookies are available online.